Strategy · Direct Indexing

Direct Indexing: The complete guide.

Direct Indexing is an investing strategy that can help you improve your after-tax returns. It's especially useful when you have capital gains to offset (e.g. appreciated stocks/RSUs). The strategy owns the individual stocks of an index (e.g. S&P 500), captures losses during market dips, and offsets gains.

This guide covers how Direct Indexing works, the situations where it pays off, and when Long/Short may be the better strategy.

This guide provides general information rather than personalized investment, tax, or legal advice. The numbers and frameworks describe how the relevant strategies typically work for the broad population of tech employees with concentrated equity, but they cannot account for your specific cost basis, vesting schedule, state of residence, marriage status, charitable intent, estate plan, AMT carryforwards, or holding-period clocks, all of which materially change the answer in any individual case. To run the numbers on your actual situation, talk to an advisor.

In short
What it is
Owning the stocks of an index directly, so you can sell the ones that fall and use the losses to cut your tax bill.
What's the impact
Average tax-loss harvesting of 28% of the amount invested, close to 50% in favorable scenarios, over a 10-year period.1
Best for
Selling appreciated stock or RSUs gradually, offsetting other gains, and banking losses for gains still to come.
Not for
Investors with no gains to offset, or a single large low-basis position that needs more losses than long-only harvesting can make.
Part one.
How Direct Indexing works and what it is worth

What Direct Indexing is and why it matters for taxable investors

Direct Indexing is an investment strategy in which you own the individual stocks that make up a market index inside a separately managed account, rather than buying an ETF. Because you hold each stock directly, you can sell any stock that falls below its purchase price and realize a capital loss. You then reinvest the proceeds in a similar stock so your portfolio keeps tracking the index. The strategy is also called personalized indexing or a tax-loss harvesting SMA.

Loss harvesting lowers cost basis, so the taxes may be deferred rather than eliminated. Harvesting depends on market conditions and is not guaranteed. The benefit may slow down in later years, as most holdings increase in value. Direct Indexing accounts will have a tracking error against the index and performance may deviate from it. Visuals are illustrative only. Shapes show how the mechanism works and are not drawn to scale, not based on an actual account, and not a projection of results.

How tax-loss harvesting turns market dips into tax savings

Tax-loss harvesting means selling a stock that is worth less than its purchase price and immediately buying a similar company, so your money stays invested and your portfolio keeps tracking the index. The sale locks in a capital loss on paper. That loss offsets capital gains elsewhere in your household. Losses in excess of gains can offset up to $3,000 of ordinary income a year under Section 1211. Losses beyond that threshold carry forward indefinitely for use in future years.

Loss harvesting works even when the market is up. An index holds hundreds of stocks, and in almost any quarter some of them are down, so there is usually something to harvest.

178
S&P 500 companies that lost value in Q4 20232
+11.7%
The S&P 500's gain in the same quarter

A simple example: Coca-Cola falls below what you paid, so the account sells it and buys PepsiCo, a similar company. Your exposure to consumer staples barely changes, and you now have a loss to use. Multiply that across hundreds of stocks and many market dips, and the losses add up.

This extra after-tax return is often called tax alpha. The savings are real money you keep invested, and they compound. Say a $250,000 account harvests $30,000 of losses in a year. Used against gains taxed at 37 percent, that saves $11,100 of tax. Left invested, those savings keep growing for as long as you stay invested.

Tax saved on a $30,000 harvested loss, reinvested
Hypothetical: a $30,000 loss, about 12% of a $250,000 account, used against gains taxed at 37%, with the savings invested and growing at an assumed 7% a year. Not a projection of any account. Because replacement stocks are bought at lower prices, some of the tax may come due when they are eventually sold.

How much Direct Indexing harvests over time

"Beyond Direct Indexing," a 2023 study by Liberman, Krasner, Sosner and Freitas in The Journal of Beta Investment Strategies, simulated 27 ten-year periods from 1986 to 2021. On average, a one-time Direct Indexing investment harvested losses equal to 28 percent of the amount invested over ten years.1 Put simply: for every $100 you invest, expect roughly $28 of harvested losses over a decade, most of it early.

28%
Average losses harvested over ten yearsas a share of the amount invested

That average hides a wide range and depends on market conditions. Direct Indexing harvests the most when markets are trending downwards, because more stocks fall below their purchase price. In decades when the index returned about 5 percent a year, ten-year losses reached about 50 percent of the amount invested; in decades with 16 percent returns, only about 5 percent.

Ten-year losses harvested, by how the market did
Weak marketsIndex return about 5% a year
About 50%
Average marketsIndex return about 11% a year
About 30%
Strong marketsIndex return about 16% a year
About 5%
The 27 simulated decades split into thirds by average index return. Source: Liberman, Krasner, Sosner and Freitas, "Beyond Direct Indexing: Dynamic Direct Long-Short Investing," The Journal of Beta Investment Strategies, Fall 2023, p. 7 and Exhibit B1. Hypothetical.

Loss harvesting tends to be most effective in the early years, and levels off over time: on average 13 percent in the first year, 21 percent by the third, and just under 30 percent after about eight.

Average losses harvested over time, as a share of the amount invested
Average across 27 simulated ten-year periods. Most losses arrive in the first three years, then the total levels off. Source: Liberman, Krasner, Sosner and Freitas, "Beyond Direct Indexing: Dynamic Direct Long-Short Investing," The Journal of Beta Investment Strategies, Fall 2023, Exhibit 1. Simulated Russell 1000 portfolios, one-time investment, gross of fees. Hypothetical; not a projection.
"Direct Indexing harvests the most in the years the market disappoints, which is when a tax break is most welcome."

Estimate what Direct Indexing could be worth for you

Enter an amount and choose what the losses would offset. The estimate applies the study's average and strong-case ten-year results to top California tax rates, so you can see both the typical outcome and the upside. Short-term gains are where each dollar of loss is worth the most: up to 54 cents.

What would the losses offset?
Average case
$75,700
in potential tax savings over 10 years, from $140,000 of losses (28% of the amount invested)
Strong case
$154,200
in potential tax savings over 10 years, from $285,000 of losses (57% of the amount invested)

Hypothetical. Losses from the study's simulated average (28%) and strong case (90th percentile, 57%) after 10 years for a one-time investment; taxed at up to 54.1% (37% federal, 3.8% NIIT, 13.3% California). Assumes you have enough gains or income to use the losses. Not guaranteed; before fees and trading costs. Harvesting lowers your cost basis, so part of the benefit is deferred tax.

Want the estimate run on your own stock, gains and tax bracket?
Part two.
When Direct Indexing is worth it

The situations where Direct Indexing pays off

Direct Indexing pays off when harvested losses have something to cancel: gains from selling appreciated stock or RSUs, a business or property sale, short-term trading gains, or ordinary income up to $3,000 a year. It also helps when you want to stop adding to a company you already depend on. Pick the situation closest to yours.

Diversify out of appreciated stock, a slice at a time

You hold employer stock or vested RSU shares that have grown a lot, and selling it all at once would mean a big tax bill.

  1. 1Sell a slice of the stock each year
  2. 2Invest the proceeds in Direct Indexing
  3. 3Losses from the new portfolio offset the next sale's gain

The common thread here is having a steady supply of gains. Investors with recurring gains, a high tax bracket and regular new money to invest get the most from it, because new money starts fresh positions that harvest well and gains give the losses somewhere to go.

When a low-cost ETF is the better choice

Direct Indexing costs more than an index ETF and generates more paperwork, so it only earns its keep when the losses can be used. A plain ETF is usually the better choice in four situations.

  1. You have no gains to offset, now or aheadLosses beyond $3,000 a year just carry forward. If no gains are coming, they may never be used.
  2. The money is in an IRA or 401(k)Tax-advantaged accounts do not pay capital gains tax, so there is nothing to harvest against.
  3. You are in a low tax bracketEach dollar of loss saves less, and the extra cost and paperwork can outweigh it.
  4. You need the money within a few yearsSelling the whole account soon can bring back much of the deferred gain at once.

How to customize a portfolio around your stock and your values

Because you own each stock, the portfolio can be shaped around your situation. The most common use for tech employees is excluding a current or former employer's stock, so the portfolio stops adding to the concentration you already carry through RSUs and options. The same tools handle values screens and, for some investors, factor tilts.

How a personalized index is built
  1. 1Pick a benchmarkS&P 500, total market, or a global index.
  2. 2Exclude what you already ownYour employer's stock, its sector, or names you avoid.
  3. 3Apply your values or tiltsESG screens, or factor tilts if they fit your plan.
  4. 4Plan the transitionMove existing stock in at a pace your tax budget allows.
  5. 5Harvest and rebalanceLosses captured as prices move; the portfolio stays on track.

Benchmark choice. Pick the index that matches your goals, from the S&P 500 to a total-market or global index. The harvesting mechanics are the same.

Exclusions. Remove your employer, its sector, or names that would create wash-sale conflicts with stock held elsewhere. The more you exclude, the more the portfolio can drift from the index.

ESG screens and factor tilts. Apply ESG or values screens to leave out fossil fuels, weapons or tobacco, or tilt toward value, quality or momentum. If a factor tilt is all you want, a factor ETF is often simpler and cheaper.

Household coordination. Section 1091 applies to you as a taxpayer, not to one account, so a loss in one account can be undone by a purchase in another. Advisor-led accounts can coordinate across a spouse's accounts, IRAs and trusts. You can see how we put this together on our Direct Indexing service page.

CapabilityRobo-advisorsAdvisor-led accounts
Minimum investmentOften a few thousand dollarsOften $100,000 to $250,000 or more
Moving in existing stockLimited; some sell transferred stock automaticallyA transition plan built around your gains budget
Exclusions and screensStock exclusions and pre-built screensCustom exclusions, sector limits and screens
Wash-sale coordinationWithin the provider's own accountsAcross household accounts, including IRAs and a spouse's
Source: InverseWealth research on typical industry offerings as of October 2026. Minimums, fees and capabilities vary by provider and change often.
For general comparison only; not a description of any specific provider.
Sounds like your situation? See how InverseWealth builds and manages Direct Indexing.
Part three.
Direct Indexing or Long/Short?

How Direct Indexing helps you diversify appreciated stock

To diversify a concentrated stock position with Direct Indexing, you sell your stock in slices, invest the proceeds in a Direct Indexing account, and use loss harvesting to offset some of the gain. You can also transfer shares in-kind to a direct indexing account, set a capital gains budget, and let the manager sell them down against harvested losses.1 If you are still deciding whether to sell at all, see our guide to selling vs holding RSUs.

Case Study

Mila is a senior product manager at Google. Years of RSUs have left her with $1 million of GOOG, a big share of her savings in one stock. She paid about half that, so selling it all at once would hand a large slice of the gain to taxes.

Position
$1M of GOOG
Cost basis
$500K
Goal
Diversify over 5 years

The plan: sell a fifth of the GOOG each year and invest the proceeds in Direct Indexing tracking the S&P 500. The losses it harvests offset the gain on the next sale.

$60,400less tax over five years, about a third of the bill
How her portfolio shifts from GOOG to the S&P 500
GOOGS&P 500 through Direct Indexing

Hypothetical illustration. Each $200,000 sale realizes a $100,000 gain taxed at 37.1% (20% federal, 3.8% NIIT, 13.3% California): $185,500 of tax over five years without harvesting. After-tax proceeds invested; losses follow the study's simulated average, about $162,900 over five years. No fees or transaction costs. In weak markets the savings could be about a third of this; in strong markets, about twice. Actual results will differ.

When Long/Short is the better tool

Direct Indexing has a ceiling: on average, loss harvesting levels off near 28 percent of the amount invested, and about 50 percent in strong cases. That covers many RSU situations, but not a position where the gain is more than about half its value. A Long/Short strategy addresses that by using margin to add long and short positions on top of the index portfolio, creating more chances to realize losses. In the study's simulations, a 150/50 Long/Short portfolio harvested losses equal to the full amount invested in about seven years.1

Years until harvested losses equal the full amount invested
Direct Indexing
Not reached: levels off near 28%
150/50 Long/Short
About 7 years
200/100 Long/Short
Under 3 years
250/150 Long/Short
Under 2 years
Averages across simulated ten-year periods; shorter bars mean losses build faster. Source: Liberman, Krasner, Sosner and Freitas, "Beyond Direct Indexing: Dynamic Direct Long-Short Investing," The Journal of Beta Investment Strategies, Fall 2023, pp. 7–8. Gross of fees and financing. Hypothetical.

The extra losses come with real costs. Short positions need a margin account and borrowing, returns can drift further from the index, and trading is heavier. The exit is the hardest part: unwinding back to a plain index fund realizes most of the gains the strategy deferred, so investors usually step down to a lighter 130/30 or 150/50 mix rather than exit fully. The study's authors concluded that Direct Indexing suits investors whose other investments realize short-term gains, while Tax-Aware Long/Short is much better suited to low-basis concentrated positions.

Case Study
Raj · NVIDIA · Early engineer · $1M NVDA · $100K cost basis
Gains to offset$900K
Direct Indexing$280K–$500K over 10 years
Long/ShortThe full $900K in about 7 years

Raj's gain is about $900,000, 90 percent of the position. Direct Indexing on a $1 million account would harvest roughly $280,000 to $500,000 over ten years, a third to a half of the gain. A 150/50 Long/Short strategy could offset all of it in about seven years, in exchange for margin, borrowing costs and returns that can drift further from the index.

Hypothetical illustration using the study's simulated results: Direct Indexing's average (28%) to strong case (about 50%) after ten years, and the 150/50 average. Gross of management fees. Long/Short results vary more than Direct Indexing's and are not guaranteed.

Choose Direct Indexing if

  • You sell RSUs or appreciated stock gradually
  • Your other investments throw off gains
  • You want to stay close to the index
  • You want simple costs and no leverage

Consider Long/Short if

  • One low-basis position dominates your net worth
  • Long-only losses would cover only part of the gain
  • You are comfortable with margin and short positions
  • You can stay invested for many years
Quick check: which approach fits?
1Do you have capital gains to offset, now or in the next few years?
2Is most of the gain in one stock you've held a long time (low cost basis)?
3Are you comfortable with margin, short positions and returns that can drift further from the index?
4Do you plan to stay invested for five years or more?

Answer the four questions to see a starting point.

How Direct Indexing compares with other concentrated-stock strategies

Direct Indexing and Long/Short are not the only ways to deal with a large, appreciated position. An Exchange Fund defers the tax entirely by pooling your shares into a diversified partnership, but it locks your capital up for seven years. The Section 351 ETF Exchange is a separate vehicle that also defers tax at contribution, without the lockup but with no ongoing harvesting. A Charitable Remainder Trust sells your stock without tax up front and pays you income for life or a set term, with the remainder going to charity.

VehicleTax treatmentLiquidityBest use case
Direct IndexingOngoing loss harvesting offsets gainsDailyTaxable accounts with recurring gains
Long/ShortMuch larger loss harvesting; deferralDaily, but costly to unwindLarge low-basis positions
Exchange FundFull deferral until redemption7-year lockupLarge concentrated positions, long horizon
Section 351 ETF ExchangeDeferral at contribution; no ongoing harvestingDaily after formationConcentrated positions needing liquidity
Charitable Remainder TrustNo tax when the trust sells; gains taxed as income is paid out; partial charitable deductionIrrevocable; you receive an income streamCharitably inclined holders who want income
Source: InverseWealth research, drawing on published materials from each category. Terms vary by provider.
For general comparison only. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

For a deeper side-by-side, see Exchange Fund vs CRT vs Direct Indexing.

Not sure whether Direct Indexing, Long/Short or a mix fits your position?
Part four.
Costs, risks and planning the exit

What Direct Indexing costs and what can go wrong

Direct Indexing typically costs from about 0.09 percent a year on a robo-advisor to 1 percent or more from a traditional advisor, compared with about 0.03 percent for a broad-market ETF. The fee is worth paying when the harvested losses save more tax than it costs, which is usually the case in a high bracket with gains to offset. The other costs are less visible.

  1. Tracking errorOwning individual stocks means returns differ slightly from the index. The study's simulated portfolios averaged about 1.2 percent a year of tracking error; exclusions and screens add more.
  2. PaperworkHundreds of positions mean hundreds of 1099 line items. Consolidated tax reports help, but your accountant will notice.
  3. Slowing harvestsMost losses arrive in the first few years. After that, new losses depend on market drops or new money.
  4. Wash salesA repurchase of the same stock within 30 days, in any of your household's accounts, can cancel a harvested loss. See the next section.
  5. No guaranteeIn strong markets, harvests can be small. Tax savings depend on markets and your tax situation.

How the wash sale rule can cancel a harvested loss

The wash sale rule under Section 1091 disallows a loss if you buy the same or a substantially identical security within 30 days before or after the sale, a 61-day window. The disallowed loss is not gone for good in a taxable account: it is added to the cost basis of the replacement shares, so the benefit is deferred. But a harvested loss you were counting on this year can disappear, and in some cases it is lost permanently.

  1. It applies to your whole householdThe rule looks at every account you or your spouse control: other brokerage accounts, IRAs, 401(k)s and trusts you control. A purchase in any of them can cancel a loss in the Direct Indexing account.
  2. A repurchase in an IRA can lose the deduction for goodIf the replacement shares are bought in an IRA or Roth IRA, the IRS has ruled the loss is disallowed and is not added to the IRA's basis (Revenue Ruling 2008-5).
  3. Watch your own company's stockIf you harvest a loss on your employer's stock, an RSU vest or an ESPP purchase within 30 days counts as buying it back. Many tech employees trigger wash sales this way without noticing.
  4. Automatic purchases countReinvested dividends, automatic investments and 401(k) contributions into a fund that holds the same stock can all be repurchases. Broad index funds are generally treated as different securities from individual stocks, but two funds tracking the same index may be treated as substantially identical.
  5. What counts as substantially identicalDifferent companies, even in the same industry, are not substantially identical: Coca-Cola and PepsiCo are fine. Two share classes of the same company, or a stock and an option on it, are.

Managers avoid wash sales inside the account by buying a similar company rather than the one just sold, and by waiting at least 31 days before buying it back. The harder part is everything outside the account: your 401(k), your spouse's trades, your RSU vests. That is why household-level coordination matters, and why we review all of a household's accounts before harvesting.

Planning your exit before the tax bomb

Harvesting works by lowering your cost basis, so a long-running Direct Indexing account gradually fills with unrealized gains. After a decade of rising markets, much of the account's value can be gain that comes due whenever you sell, for a home purchase, a divorce or a business investment. The harvesting wins you banked along the way do not offset what you owe at exit, so the best time to plan the exit is when you open the account.

Give the winners away

Donate the most appreciated shares to charity or a donor-advised fund. You deduct their full value, within limits of 30 percent of AGI under Section 170, and the gain is never taxed.3

Hold for the step-up

Under Section 1014, heirs inherit shares at their value on the date of death, so lifetime gains on those shares are never taxed.

Add a Long/Short extension

When long-only harvesting has slowed, short positions can generate new losses, with margin, financing costs and a harder exit later.

"The harvesting engine runs hot in early years and cools as cost basis catches up to current prices. Plan a five-to-ten-year arc, not a perpetual machine."

Death, carryforwards and other edge cases

At death, the treatment flips. Heirs receive a stepped-up cost basis, which wipes out the embedded gains, but unused loss carryforwards die with you. If you have large accumulated losses late in life, consider realizing gains to use them, or giving appreciated shares to charity.

The $3,000 ordinary income offset under Section 1211 is easy to overlook. In the top federal and California brackets, it saves about $1,500 a year, and whatever is left keeps carrying forward under Section 1212 for future gains.

When an advisor adds value

The harvesting itself is automated on every platform. What an advisor adds is judgment around it: which tool fits your position, how to move your existing stock in, and how to keep the whole household's taxes working together. The decisions around it are where most of the value is won or lost.

  1. Choosing the right toolDirect Indexing, Long/Short or an Exchange Fund depends on your cost basis, your other gains and your timeline. Getting this choice right matters more than any single harvest.
  2. A transition plan for the stock you already ownHow fast to sell, around vesting dates, trading windows (or a 10b5-1 plan) and a yearly tax budget you set, rather than selling transferred stock all at once.
  3. One portfolio, not a single indexAn advisor can run Direct Indexing on a wide range of indexes and hold other ETFs, such as bonds, in the same account for a complete plan. Most robo-advisors offer a set menu of stock indexes and keep other asset classes in separate products.
  4. Changing course as life changesThe benchmark, exclusions and strategy can be adjusted as your goals, job or tax situation shift, including a move toward Long/Short when long-only harvesting slows, instead of staying tied to one preset index.
  5. Wash sales across the householdRSU vests, ESPP purchases, a spouse's trades and IRAs can all cancel a harvested loss. Most robo-advisors only see their own accounts.
  6. Planning the exitDeciding which appreciated shares to give, hold or transition, so the deferred tax does not arrive all at once.

This is how we run Direct Indexing at InverseWealth. See how it works.

Related strategies

Other ways to unwind concentrated stock

Decisions like this are easier with a fiduciary in the room.

InverseWealth is a fee-only RIA that advises tech professionals on concentrated stock, RSU diversification, and tax-efficient portfolio construction. No commissions, no product sales—just advice aligned with your outcome.

Talk to an advisorSee InverseWealth Direct Indexing
FAQ

Frequently asked questions.

General information, not personalized tax or investment advice.

Is Direct Indexing worth it?

It is worth it when you have capital gains to offset, now or soon, and a taxable account large enough for the harvested losses to matter. In a 2023 study in The Journal of Beta Investment Strategies, a one-time investment harvested losses averaging about 28 percent of the amount invested over ten years, and close to 50 percent in strong cases. Those losses only save tax if you have gains or income to use them against. If you have neither and do not need to exclude any stocks, a low-cost index ETF is simpler and cheaper.

How long does Direct Indexing continue to generate tax losses?

Most of the losses arrive early. In a 2023 study in The Journal of Beta Investment Strategies, a one-time investment harvested an average of 13 percent of the amount invested in year one and 21 percent by year three, then leveled off just under 30 percent after about eight years. By then most positions sit above their cost, and new losses come mainly from market corrections. Adding new money, or donating the most appreciated shares and replacing them with cash, restarts the harvesting.

Direct Indexing or Long/Short: which is better for concentrated stock?

For most people diversifying RSUs or appreciated stock gradually, Direct Indexing is enough. Long/Short makes sense for a large, low-basis position where long-only losses would cover only a fraction of the gain. In a 2023 study in The Journal of Beta Investment Strategies, a 150/50 Long/Short portfolio harvested losses equal to the full amount invested in about seven years, while long-only Direct Indexing leveled off near 28 percent. Long/Short brings margin, financing costs, more tracking error and a harder exit.

Does the wash sale rule apply across all my accounts?

Yes. Section 1091 applies to all accounts you own or control, including IRAs, 401(k)s and accounts held by your spouse. If you sell a stock at a loss in your taxable Direct Indexing account and your 401(k) buys the same security within 30 days before or after the sale, the loss is disallowed. The loss is added to the cost basis of the replacement shares, deferring but not eliminating the benefit. Coordination across accounts is essential for effective tax-loss harvesting.

What is the minimum investment for Direct Indexing?

Minimums vary widely by provider. Robo-advisors can start at a few thousand dollars, while advisor-led accounts with deeper customization and household-level wash-sale coordination often start around $100,000 to $250,000 or more. Because minimums change often, the better question is whether you have gains to offset and a large enough taxable balance for the harvested losses to matter. We can help you compare the options for your situation.

How does Direct Indexing compare to holding a low-cost ETF?

An ETF is cheaper (expense ratios near 0.03 percent) and simpler, but it offers no loss-harvesting opportunity and no customization. Direct Indexing costs more (from about 0.09 percent a year on a robo-advisor to 1 percent or more from a traditional advisor) and adds administrative complexity with hundreds of 1099 line items. In a 2023 study in The Journal of Beta Investment Strategies, however, it harvested losses averaging about 28 percent of the amount invested over ten years, most of it in the first few years, which is valuable for investors with gains to offset. If you do not have gains to offset and do not need customization, a low-cost ETF is the better choice.

Can I harvest losses myself instead of using Direct Indexing?

You can, but with funds the opportunities are rarer. Harvesting an ETF means waiting for the whole fund to fall below what you paid, then swapping into a fund that tracks a different index. Direct Indexing harvests at the level of each stock, so it finds losses even when the index is up. Doing that by hand across hundreds of stocks, while avoiding wash sales against RSU vests, ESPP purchases and your other accounts, is impractical for most people, which is why the harvesting is automated.

Can I fund a Direct Indexing account with existing stock instead of cash?

Yes. Most providers accept in-kind transfers of existing stock. You contribute your shares, and the manager transitions the portfolio toward the target index over time, selling your concentrated position in stages and harvesting losses along the way to offset the gains. This approach is particularly effective for diversifying concentrated stock positions because the harvesting engine immediately begins generating losses to offset the gains from selling your original holding.

What happens to unharvested losses when I die?

At death, your heirs receive a stepped-up cost basis on inherited assets, which eliminates the embedded gains in your portfolio. However, the step-up also eliminates any unused capital loss carryforwards—losses you harvested but did not use die with you. If you have substantial accumulated losses and anticipate death, consider realizing gains to use the losses or gifting appreciated shares to charity while alive to capture the full fair-market-value deduction.

What does substantially identical mean under the wash sale rule?

The IRS has not defined substantially identical precisely, but it has consistently held that different companies in the same industry are not substantially identical. Coca-Cola and PepsiCo are correlated but legally distinct, so selling Coca-Cola at a loss and buying PepsiCo is permitted. Two share classes of the same company, or a stock and an option on that stock, are substantially identical. Most advisors treat ETFs tracking the same index as substantially identical out of caution.

Sources
Footnotes
  1. 1. Liberman, Krasner, Sosner and Freitas, "Beyond Direct Indexing: Dynamic Direct Long-Short Investing," The Journal of Beta Investment Strategies, Fall 2023. Simulated Russell 1000 portfolios, 27 ten-year histories starting each January from 1986 to 2012, one-time investment with no further contributions, top 2022 federal tax rates, gross of management fees. Weak and strong cases are the 10th and 90th percentiles. Charts on this page are drawn by InverseWealth from the paper's published figures. Results vary with market returns and volatility and are not guaranteed.
  2. 2. Vanguard, "What is direct indexing?", citing FactSet data as of December 31, 2023.
  3. 3. Internal Revenue Code Section 170(b)(1)(C) caps the charitable deduction for long-term appreciated property at 30% of AGI. Excess deductions carry forward five years.

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

Advisory services are offered by InverseWealth LLC, a registered Investment Advisor in the State of California. Being registered as an investment adviser does not imply a certain level of skill or training. The information contained herein should in no way be construed or interpreted as a solicitation to sell or offer to sell advisory services to any residents of any State other than the State of California or where otherwise legally permitted.

All content is for information purposes only. It is not intended to provide any tax or legal advice or provide the basis for any financial decisions. Nor is it intended to be a projection of current or future performance or indication of future results.

Any tools or calculators are provided for informational purposes only. They may contain errors or produce incomplete or inaccurate estimates. InverseWealth makes no warranties about the accuracy of any estimate. Consult a qualified professional before making any decision. InverseWealth does not assume any liability for errors, omissions or damages that may arise from the use of these tools.

Opinions expressed herein are solely those of InverseWealth LLC and our editorial staff. The information contained in this material has been derived from sources believed to be reliable but is not guaranteed as to accuracy and completeness and does not purport to be a complete analysis of the materials discussed. All information and ideas should be discussed in detail with your individual adviser prior to implementation.

All investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Diversification is not a guarantee against loss. Active risk management strategies are not a guarantee against loss. Past performance is not a guarantee or indication of future results.

Images and photographs are included for the sole purpose of visually enhancing the website. None of them are photographs of current or former Clients. They should not be construed as an endorsement or testimonial from any of the persons in the photograph.

Purchases are subject to suitability. This requires a review of an investor's objective, risk tolerance, and time horizons. Investing always involves risk and possible loss of capital.

Consult a qualified tax professional before implementing strategies. InverseWealth does not offer legal or tax advice.

Required disclosures: Form ADV. California-registered investment adviser · CRD # 333749.