Strategy 4 — Direct indexing with tax-loss harvesting
Direct indexing replicates a benchmark (most often the S&P 500 or a broad total-market index) at the security level inside a separately managed account, holding hundreds of individual stocks instead of an ETF. The structural value is that lot-level losses become available for harvest. When a single name dips, the SMA sells the lot at a loss, realizes the deductible capital loss under IRC Section 1091's wash-sale constraints, and replaces the position with a non-substantially-identical correlated stock so the index tracking remains tight.
AQR's 2023 study,Beyond Direct Indexing, simulated a one-time direct-indexing investment over 27 ten-year periods. Net harvested losses averaged about 13% of the amount invested in year one, 21% by year three and about 28% after ten years, with the range driven by how the market did. The harvest is front-loaded, but the losses apply against gains realized anywhere in the household, including the gradual unwind of the concentrated position.
Wash-sale risk is the operational constraint. Section 1091 applies across all of the donor's accounts (and a spouse's, if filing jointly), including IRAs. Most SMA providers manage internal wash-sale exposure but cannot see what the client trades elsewhere; the burden of avoiding parallel buys in the same names sits with the client. When the concentrated position is held in a different account at the same broker, providers typically exclude that ticker from the SMA universe at client instruction.
Worked figure. A $1M direct-indexing account funded at once harvested about $130K of net losses in its first year at AQR's average, and about $280K over ten years. Used against long-term gains at a combined 37.1% California rate, the first year's losses are worth about $48K in tax, much of it deferred rather than eliminated, and before management fees. The structure earns its fee when the household has an ongoing capital-gain pipeline (RSU vesting, concentrated unwind, secondary liquidity) rather than as a standalone bet.
Long-form prose covering harvest decay, factor-tilt variants, and the breakeven framework against the concentrated unwind speed lives in the direct indexing guide.